This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/relationships by /u/PastSelect on 2024-01-23 11:14:51+00:00.
Around 1.5 months ago I (F26) reconnected with a highschool friend (M27). The initial idea was FWB since neither of us wanted a relationship back then. But as soon as we started talking we felt like there could be more to this. He called me every day from that moment on. We could talk for hours on end. It felt like we have known eachother for ages. It felt so easy and right. All times when we saw eachother were amazing. We were intimate and it just felt right. I felt like I'd found my person if I am honest. He confessed that he had a crush on me in highschool, which I also did. He told me that I am the brightest light to have walked into his life for a long time and that he is going to take care of me.
There is only one complication, the fact that he was already dating someone else. The girl was my ex's ex, so I knew her. When we reconnected they weren't dating seriously. She told him that she isn't in the right space for a relationship. That changed over the past 1.5 months, when she told him that there might be more to their connection. They already had a history back in 2017, when they were also dating but he fucked up by also dating someone else who made their thing public. This hurt her a lot and he thought that this door was closed forever. Until... now. He told me that he regretted a lot of his decisions back then.
So. Two weeks ago he told me that he had to make a decision and I agreed. Because he couldn't start to grow feelings for both of us. Although he had the chance to tell the other woman of me and get some clarity back then, he didn't. He said that she has enough on her plate as is and that she is very closed off. We kept in touch the same way as before until yesterday. Yesterday we decided to take a walk and he told me that he had chosen her. Because of their history. He confessed that he also had developed feelings for me, but that he can't go on with his life if he does not take the chance with her now since he fucked up 7 years ago. If he would not do that he would continue to ask himself what would have come of it. When I started crying he pulled me in and gave me a kiss on my forehead telling me that everything will be alright and that if we are meant for eachother we will find a way. And that he is so sorry for hurting me this much. He said that this decision was extremely hard to make for him and that he'd never expected to be in such a situation. He confessed that this hurt him a lot aswell even if it might not seem like it at the moment. He kissed me twice yesterday. He doesn't want to lose me, but he understands that I need distance. He really hopes to meet me again in the future and he doesn't care if that is as friends or as lovers. He cares a lot about me and hopes that I will be happy. He even told me that his door will always be open for me and that even if we remeet in a nursing home he would still count himself lucky, because I am an amazing woman to him.
So. I feel like my heart has been ripped out. The last time I felt this much for a person was with my last partner of 8 years, which ended 1 year ago. I honestly feel like I can't fall in love anymore. I truly felt that everything just clicked and finally made sense.This hurts so much and I just can't wrap my head around why this did not work out. When I asked him why does something that feels so right still is not enough, he answered me that it is not about me or it not being enough but it is a wrong time, wrong place, right person scenario where he just can't let go of the opportunity with the other woman.
TL;DR: Remeeting and dating old highschool friend who choses old flame.