The idea of something being "not good enough for Lemmy" kinda amuses me a little bit. I mean, I get we're trying to do some decent stuff around here, but look around. This place is still pretty roughshod.
this post was submitted on 25 Nov 2023
221 points (95.9% liked)
Asklemmy
44115 readers
1195 users here now
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
Search asklemmy π
If your post meets the following criteria, it's welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- [email protected]: a community for finding communities
~Icon~ ~by~ ~@Double_[email protected]~
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
We had a post about not pooping for 3 days as one of the main things to happen here. Any art project is good enough for lemmy lol
Nothing is good enough for Lemmy. Anything you post will inevitably be downvoted. Because users here care more about making sure the world knows they don't personally like something than about encouraging original content.
This statement is false
God haha that is bad. I do not know why people are like this, but for me personally all my posts across two accounts are at above 95% ratio, so not every post is thoroughly downvoted.
The one type of post that always seems to get downvoted is any low-level question about any particular field, are beginners just not supposed to have questions?
The lack of project-based content is just due to size and a lack of engagement. Try engaging and see if anyone else joins in π
I think the main reason lemmy is mostly news, memes and discussion atm is that thats something everyone can do/ participate in. And since there arent that many users right now, thats what most content is.
Though I for one would be very happy to see such projects: self-made art, music, crafting, cooking, whatever else people are up to. And I dont think im alone in that
Can't speak for everyone, but I'd love to see more personal projects done by others posted on Lemmy--whether it's something god-teir or mediocre (because well, what you may call mediocre, some might call pretty good. Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder and all that).
Tldr: I say POST AWAY! I WANNA SEE YOUR PROJECTS!
As I've progressed in skill in some hobbies, I see people posting "Incredible work! I love ______!" on something that, to be honest, is mediocre at best.
But guess what! It is incredible work, because someone put their time and skill into it, and every new thing they make is advancing their skill. Whether you personally have surpassed that level, or not, is irrelevant.
I love seeing people post their rough drafts, their works in progress, the thing they JUST got into last week and this is their first attempt.
Every master craftsman started out with their first project. And it probably wasn't very good. But who cares, it's their passion, and they stuck with it.
I make knives and swords as a hobby, and sell some on occasion. I actually still have my very first knife sitting on my bench. I use it every time I make a new one. My second knife was bought by a friend for $40, and he still has it. Won't sell it back to me even though I've offered more recent ones in trade plus the original 40. Because I made it, and even though more recent stuff may look fancier, and probably much higher quality, it was important to me, and therefore to him. I don't think he realizes how much hearing that meant to me.
So sure, a couple people might go in pointing out flaws and calling it bad, but you made it, you put time and effort into it, it's worthy of my screen time. I'm excited to see what you change or improve on next time!
Maybe we should grow c/imadethis Edit: trying a proper way to link⦠[email protected]
Interface is telling me you have two replies but won't let me see them so if this is a repeat, apologies! But [email protected] is already an active thing, probably don't need two :D
Also see my other comment in this thread for an off-the-top-of-my-head list of creative project type communities.
The other replies are bots. You may have hide bots enabled.
That does sound like me!
Hi there! Looks like you linked to a Lemmy community using a URL instead of its name, which doesn't work well for people on different instances. Try fixing it like this: [email protected]
Thanks bot. I have already fixed it.
My imposter syndrome also kicks into high gear and tells me that my creations just arenβt good enough to be on Lemmy, and I shouldnβt taint peopleβs feeds with my mediocre endeavors; after all, I and plenty of other people are enjoying the content here as-is.
A cool thing with Lemmy (or the fedi) is that it's not yet full of professional artists trying to get sponsor and sell you stuff. So even if you're an amateur please share. We need to see more "sloppy content" done with "real finger", during the 2 hour free you had between work and cooking/eating dinner.
slop is an aesthetic ive recently got into. everyone should post their garbagecore creations, its cool.
Definitely. There is a small but growing community at [email protected] for example. There are many creative communities here.
Thanks for sharing that, and to add on, so far I've found:
Both of which specialise in members sharing their own work.
Brilliant
Yes please share.
Not mentioned yet, but [email protected] is a good place to share art specifically.
I second this. I've seen some great stuff there.
this is the reason there are 50,000 instances across the fediverse. there are absolutely instances meant for personal project content like crafting.
the searching across instances is still stupid, i know there are a few projects out there attempting to build cross-fediverse content searching.
so it really depends on your project, and how specific a community you want to post it in
I've shared my "MS Paint"-like sockpuppet parody impressions over at !sockpuppetsociety as well as my own twists on memes and anime screenshot comics and such in !animepics, !animemes, etc. If I can post this and this and this and this, you can post something you made too.
Just find the right community for your art and maybe some people will enjoy it.
Don't be surprised if people blow raspberries at your work though; that's just kind of what people do with art. :p
Hi there! Looks like you linked to a Lemmy community using a URL instead of its name, which doesn't work well for people on different instances. Try fixing it like this: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
Feel free! Probably [email protected] could be a good place to do this?
You can also try [email protected]
Honestly, I'm a bit bored by all the news articles. I'd love to hear about other people's personal projects, lifestyle, qualitative information, stories and perspectives.
I'm subscribed to several communities about my hobbies. Microcontrollers, Linux, Programming and other non-computer stuff. But you're right. We're mainly posting the news here. And sometimes it feels more like a regular's table discussing politics than anything of substance that would touch me.
If it were to me, I think I'd rather read about what keeps you up at night or makes you happy, than discussing the n-th news article about world politics and which country is right and who is wrong. Same for tech-news. We can have both (and I think we should). But I think we could balance it a bit with more intimate and personal perspectives. Even if it's not professionally written or a completed project.
Edit: I forgot memes
There are tons of creative / art / project focused communities here, you just don't tend to see them in the All feed for obvious reasons. Find one where your project fits, post it, worst that can happen is nobody sees it which isn't exactly the end of the world.
If you're struggling to figure out where it would fit, let us know vaguely what it is and maybe we can help! Also like someone else suggested [email protected] is a good general catch-all.
Yes, it's a great place. I would suggest trying to find a community here relating to your stuff.
Iβve been working on a graphic novel and have toyed with the idea of creating an instance and posting it here, chapter by chapter as I finish them, but sequential gallery-like image hosting is pretty bad and clunky, iirc. Does anyone know if there are any improvements slated in that regard, or if there are any solutions or workarounds to that effect?
It probably makes more sense to host your novel somewhere else and post links to it chapter by chapter.
I'd suggest doing one of the following:
- Host the images on a site that already supports image galleries and link to that. Most image hosts are kind of annoying, but this is an understandable way to do it if you don't want to run a website. (Maybe someone can chime in with a suggestion for whatever they think is the least annoying image gallery host in 2023.)
- Host the images yourself on a simple website. Webcomic artists have been doing that for many years, so there are lots of examples to draw from. (e.g. Gunnerkrigg Court)
- Zip the images up chapter by chapter and either self-host the zip or toss it on a file host like catbox.moe. If you structure it as a .cbz (i.e. zip up a folder with the images named in order like 1.jpg, 2.jpg, 3.jpg, ... and just change the extension from .zip to .cbz) then a number of document viewers (like evince) can be used to view the image sequence -- or people can just unpack the images and use their favorite image viewer on their computer.
Thanks for the detailed reply! Itβs a lot to think about, but Iβll definitely be mulling over the options! :)
I've been working on something for the Kirby community, but it's taking me time. I'd say the art and personal projects are what takes the community to the next level
Be the change you want to see in Lemmy.
I mean fuck around and find out. Most people on lemmy are pretty chill and otherwise you will notice it soon enough if people don't like it. Β―\_(γ)_/Β―
Just go ahead. I've only posted a couple of photos of one of my cats and someone even asked me to post photos of my 6x1000-pieces puzzle table that shows one corner in one of the photos. I honestly haven't found the time to take photos of the table, there's always something on it or the glass covering the puzzles makes it hard to find a suitable angle, etc. Anyway, you see my point.
I have a community for my music project, but in my experience most project sharing on the Fediverse occurs on Mastodon. There are a few Lemmy communities for production-related discussions but they don't get much traffic or visibility.
Mastodon facilitates producer talk very well. From what I've seen, it also works well for visual artists. If you don't have an account then it might be worth signing up and checking it out.
At the same time, it would be great to have more sharing and discussion occur here on Lemmy. I'm always happy to see others' work, even if they are just beginners.
You've got nothing to lose, why not?
only one way to find out, nerd
I like art and stuff, I just don't find it much. Over at !13thfloor (@13thfloor) the original creator was encouraging it so I did write an OC text using cut-up method and the lyrics that had been posted there and posted it.
Few days later I got someone contacting me asking to use it for some kind of art magik performance. So that was nice.
Not sure how to get that stuff happening more though.
Yeah, why not?