187
Does anyone else feel like Kurzgesagt is describing the Fediverse in their latest video?
(www.youtube.com)
Or just forums.
this post was submitted on 29 Nov 2023
187 points (87.9% liked)
Fediverse
28223 readers
217 users here now
A community to talk about the Fediverse and all it's related services using ActivityPub (Mastodon, Lemmy, KBin, etc).
If you wanted to get help with moderating your own community then head over to [email protected]!
Rules
- Posts must be on topic.
- Be respectful of others.
- Cite the sources used for graphs and other statistics.
- Follow the general Lemmy.world rules.
Learn more at these websites: Join The Fediverse Wiki, Fediverse.info, Wikipedia Page, The Federation Info (Stats), FediDB (Stats), Sub Rehab (Reddit Migration), Search Lemmy
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Yeah there's not much that the Fediverse adds to the equation that a forum wouldn't handle. It's actually worse in a lot of ways, because on a forum you're not going to have seven different subforums dedicated to the same topics, like the federation does by having 200 servers each with generally similar and redundant subcommunities. Sports is a big example I use, because it's the most evident.
One of the most popular moderation moves on this platform has been to lock these excess communities and forward them to a central one that is actually active.
There's some growing pains, but within a federated system, I think there needs to be community aggregation at a certain point. There's no need to host 50 different identical communities, and it's arguable that it makes things worse. I'm hoping that someone will eventually be able to develope the tools to easily allow for community aggregation in the future.
Isn't it kinda the opposite? A fediverse is not multiple separate isolated villages, it's a bunch of villages all bundled up together in one place within walking distance.
kinda. but compared to e. g. Twitter its much more splinteted. Twitter is more like one giant city. also your seeing mostly what Twitter decides. mastodon shows you what you subscribed to. things are less viral.
You can put twitters feed to following only and it's kinda the same thing tbh. I don't think Mastodon did anything to fix the core issue from the video, you're still bombarded with opinions from people you don't have much in common with. Whether it's millions of people on twitter or thousands on Mastodon, it's still more than what our stupid brain is able it process IMHO.
You're*
I do interpret it as not having an exuberant userbase atm, many share the sentiment of lemmy feeling like early internet and this is probably why. But this means once it's large enough, the same might happen to the fediverse.
But the great thing about the fediverse is how you can create your own instance and do with it as you please, maybe allow partial federation so people can read but not interact, or an entirely sepperated federation. Create your own village but still be interconnected by a high speed train network.
load more comments
(2 replies)
The villages being meaningfully separate spaces is more pertinent than how far apart they are. I'm on the instance that I'm on because of communities it federates with I'm interested in participating in. I moved instances to achieve this.
These villages were separated from each other by digital rivers or mountains
But the concept of federation in the fediverse removes these separations.
Not really, each Mastodon or Lemmy instance still has its own culture and rules. Federation just allows you to travel across borders with your same passport.
Some definitly do, but I think it depends on which one you're on and how you use it. All my communities are on other instances and unless it's an extreme instance like lemmygrad, I basically don't really care or pay attention to which instance a community is on.
Yeah you're not wrong, but just because they choose to be similar doesn't negate the ability to be different if desired, something not afforded to people who ran communities on commercial platforms.
The concept of Federation ensures the ability to do ones own thing if desired, not negate it.
The Fediverse just gives a path, it doesn't restrict the paths. Anyone can make or join any community.
load more comments
(7 replies)
Maybe they're soft launching on the fediverse 😄
Would love to see it. An explanation video on how the fediverse works, put out by Kurzgesagt, would be so helpful
Little instance-birds dying and exploding in spectacular fashion, all to a comfy jingle and a soothing narration of how the Internet is Doomed Regardless.
Kurzgesagt — in a Nutshell.
Yeah but there's literally nothing the Fediverse does better than a PHBB forum.
I actually hate the interconnected yet fragmented environment here - there's absurd amounts of redundancies in communities, resulting in dead spaces; you don't need 20 different federated servers all with their variations of the same communities, for example sports teams - you have fanaticus.social which is literally specifically for sports, but then every single local instance like midwest.social or lemmy.ca will have duplicate or even triplicate communities. This does nothing but make the whole platform seem big and empty and bereft of users or interactions.
I think once a community gets popular, the duplicates die away or act as backups when an instance goes down. That's generally a good thing because instances have disappeared overnight, and Lemmy is still in development
We had a movies&tv instance that was popular, and then it disappeared overnight so the smaller local instances took over till we got a new popular one
"literally nothing"
As if PHPBB forums didn't have duplicated subforums
If they were properly curated, they didn't. It's not like an admin from any other instance can delete duplicate communities from other instances.
Why would the admin of one PHPBB forum "curate" subforums on another PHPBB forum? If you had 10 different PHPBB forums about politics in separate countries, they would all have a "world" subforum (or something similarly named) in each. The only thing happening with the fediverse is that you're actively seeing what would happen if PHPBB forums were connected.
load more comments
(1 replies)
I remember there being at least 3 separate popular forums just for the Dodge neon.
It's pretty bad for small communities. A new factorio update drops and we have a thread on beehaw, lemmy and kbin gaming communities. Meanwhile the actual factorio community (on either of these servers) also gets a thread but it's mostly empty.
For some communities this makes sense but I feel like it just kills any smaller ones, they just never get a chance to take off properly.
It doesn't help that the fediverse search is just atrocious.
load more comments
(1 replies)
That's partilly more on the people creating duplicates without looking if the community doesn't exist already.
Granted, the lemmy explorer tool might not be around for too long for people to be easily able to - since someone on you instance needs to known a community exists on other instance and access it for everyone to see it. And some people might just not be aware of it as well.
That’s partilly more on the people creating duplicates without looking if the community doesn’t exist already
Which is not bad; actually and to the contrary, it can be a part of each instance's cultural identity and it's a practical way of ensuring the diversity and viability of smaller instances.
Discussing c/soccer in an Argentinian lemmy can be very different than discussing it in hexbear, for example. Not to mention it's likely most of everyone would't even be able to participate in hexbear's. Furthermore, general subjects becoming tied to the largest instances, which statistically have more surface to cover the creation of communities for any subject ever, returns us to the same problem of conversation and community becoming centralized into a "Reddit" instance.
A good perspective I didn't have.
load more comments
(4 replies)
load more comments
(1 replies)
If they were talking about anything specific, as hard to believe as it is, there is actually another community based website out there slightly larger than lemmy that allows you to subscribe to your interests and unsubscribe from others.
All of these things still exist. Theres just massive cities now, and they're shitty like cities in real life.
Unfortunetly for most people "go back to smaller online communities" would probably mean going from XTwitter to a Facebook group...
Here is an alternative Piped link(s):
https://piped.video/watch?v=fuFlMtZmvY0&t=23s
Piped is a privacy-respecting open-source alternative frontend to YouTube.
I'm open-source; check me out at GitHub.
I learned a lot, and made a lot of IRL friends, on various message boards over the years. ADVrider.com used to be a lot of fun but I haven't checked it out lately. One thing that was cool was looking for vehicle-specific forums, like a forum for EX-500's or F150's. These forums were great for keeping whatever car you have running, and were full of knowledge on the problems found in specific cars. A lot of them still exist.
The similarly named AVSForum is still a great resource full of insanely knowledgeable A/V nerds. The 3si forum is still the place to check if you happen to be into Mitsubishi 3000GTs or Dodge Stealths.
I miss my little crew at MarcSeal.com/forum, a small guitar community. I don't like to brag about my accomplishments, but let's just say I was a moderator.
Well... for example, I said "maybe you don't need to drag yourself through literally every bit of shitty irrelevant news, if it is stressing you out to the point of reduced quality of life" earlier - and was promptly informed there was no need to be "an uninformed idiot". So I dunno, seems pretty friendly to me.
You can do the former without being the later, fuck that person
I would be closer if every instance had a specific topic, Its much better than other social medias It would be closer if forums united through acativitypub
Instances do have quite distinct topics. This one is about programming, there are servers dedicated to specific languages, countries, or regions, others even just focus on a single game, movie, or another topic.
view more: next ›