Great. More places for the protomolecule to hang out.
this post was submitted on 12 Mar 2025
197 points (99.0% liked)
science
17939 readers
379 users here now
A community to post scientific articles, news, and civil discussion.
rule #1: be kind
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
I've seen the expanse 3 times and I'm STILL confused how the protomolecule tjrns frona fungus type thing monster to a wormhole gate lol. Maybe the books will explain it better.
expanse was one of the very rare instances where the show was better than the books. And in reading the books you really get the sense that they were written to be a script.
The books (and ultimately the show) were based on a TTRPG idea, so, yeah, they were kind of the script. Also, you can see some D&D character archetypes show through (looking at you, Jimbo "sad paladin" Holden)
agreed, the show really covered up some of what I felt was amateurish character development in the books. I actually put one of the books down for a bit when it occurred to me that itd transitioned to "zombies in space". I also wasnt too keen on the authors describing the belters as "hezbollah" at one point early in the series. But, at the end I liked them, they passed the time, and I was glad I had read them. Not great works of art, but a good space opera.
It basically needs critical mass.
The monsters were humans trying to engineer with thr molecule, that sample of protomolecule was not bound to become the ring.
On Eros, it was let loose specifically so that it could get enough mass to do what it was going to do. Think of it like a transistor- a few transistors can get you a NAND gate, but a LOT of them can give you a processor.
Once it had the critical mass and went to Venus, it was big enough that it could assimilate whatever it wanted into itself and gain the necessary mass to form the ring.
I view it like It’s a tool. Think “monolith” from 2001.
Is Saturn just a nerd that likes collecting moons or something?
A real celestial hoarder.
Saturn cheated by breaking regular moons up into many irregularly shaped moons with wonky orbits.
The truth is that there isn't a strict definition of a moon like there is now for planets. The IAU has chickened out.
Pluto is a planet and you will never convince me otherwise.
Okay!
But that means you have to recite all the planets:
- Mercury
- Venus
- Earth
- Mars
- Ceres
- Jupiter
- Saturn
- Uranus
- Neptune
- Pluto
- Eris
- Haumea
- Makemake
- Gonggong
- Orcus
- Quaoar
- Varda
- Sedna
- Possibly more…
Our moon could bully Pluto.
Edit:
Then it's a 10th planet. Ceres deserves its own spot!
They also discovered two cheeks around Uranus!
Kind of wild that with as far as technology has come they're just now seeing the crack.
And rich in hydrogen sulfate gas. Like your mom.
When is universe sandbox 2 going to update?
An excellent question!
Ring simulations are hard though, I don't expect to see a lot in that area.
I'd announce when I found just one but that wasn't good enough for some nerd
how about some fucking modesty, saturn?
Are those regular moons, or 'minor' moons?
~This~ ~comment~ ~is~ ~licensed~ ~under~ ~CC~ ~BY-NC-SA~ ~4.0~
I believe they're called moonlets. They're tiny moons, rocks that would be large enough to be called asteroids, but floating around in the rings.
Right, and I discover a new moon around earth every day.
Are the 128 moons new, or newly discovered?
within the last 100 million years
Ah, it's both!
"Moons". What do they count as moon? Anything they can track and identify? Anything larger than a football?
They took away Plutos planet status, but call every dirt blob a moon.
Same question.