1
Football to trial 10-minute sin-bins for cynical fouls as effective 'orange card'
(www.telegraph.co.uk)
this post was submitted on 28 Nov 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)
Premier League
21 readers
2 users here now
Rules
- Keep On Topic
- Give an objective and descriptive title
- No Low Content Submissions
- Provide Sources
- No Stream Requesting/Sharing
- No NSFW Content
- No Duplicate Posts
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
This will just result in more people crying about subjective fouls - why did that tackle get an orange card but this tackle didn't?.
Adding even more subjectivity into the game for fans to cry about isn't the answer.
Instead of cynical fouls, introduce that for players clasping their heads, lying on the ground in agony. That might reduce the number of players acting out and treatment and assessment can given to those that are actually injured.
They just need to have an "embellishment foul" like there is in the nhl (like this). The general nhl/hockey culture against this type of stuff helps a ton, but having a rule that even if you are fouled, if you embellish at all, you have committed a foul (and having refs that actually enforce the rule) would be amazing in my opinion.
i think a big issue with the subjective calls is how big swings they are. the difference between a yellow and a red is massive, so a call against your team feels really bad. This will just bridge the gap.
A sin bin could be great, but not with the rules written as they currently are.
Was my thoughts too. I think a sin bin would be very beneficial, although I think it should be a rule for the yellow cards.
For example, when you get a yellow card, you are sent to the sin bin for 10 mins, get another one, then you get a red card as normal. Obviously how we look at yellow cards may need to change, do they need to be slightly harder to get? Kept the same? Can VAR spot a yellow card tackle and retroactively sin bin a player?
Having a rule like this and getting the ref's mic'd up during games would go a long way in helping in my opinion.
while there may be some inconsistency players will soon twig and stop doing certain fouls.
People complaining are more of a problem than refs getting subjective calls "wrong".
Eh, idk mate. We get one tackle giving a pen one game, then later that same day the same tackle not being given. That's what frustrates people.
Two tackles are very rarely the same though.
Every call is questioned now, it's what the game has turned into.
Especially when they sin bin someone for a yellow card offence, as 5 yellow cards can carry a 1 game ban, which can also be pivotal when you have a few players sitting on 1 more for a ban.
It's for dissent and tactical fouls which are normally pretty clear cut.
Crying? You mean the Prima Donna’s crying over being fouled. They should Bin them for 5 minutes and given a yellow card to boot. I’m sure they would stop diving for a penalty or free kick. The world flow a lot better and would not be as embarrassing as it has come to be