this post was submitted on 20 Oct 2023
1205 points (96.1% liked)

Anarchist Memes

1200 readers
3 users here now

This forum is for anarchists to circlejerk and share zesty memes

founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
 
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] -3 points 1 year ago (1 children)

If you want to say more, just hit me up. I could do this all day.

I encourage you to spend the same amount of effort you put into your trolling here to educate yourself instead. Let's just look at what communism actually accomplishes. Maybe this could be start of the education you're so woefully in need of.

Russia went from a backwards agrarian society where people travelled by horse and carriage to being the first in space in the span of 40 years. Russia showed incredible growth after the revolution that surpassed the rest of the world:

USSR provided free education to all citizens resulting in literacy rising from 33% to 99.9%:

USSR doubled life expectancy in just 20 years. A newborn child in 1926-27 had a life expectancy of 44.4 years, up from 32.3 years thirty years before. In 1958-59 the life expectancy for newborns went up to 68.6 years. the Semashko system of the USSR increased lifespan by 50% in 20 years. By the 1960's, lifespans in the USSR were comparable to those in the USA:

Quality of nutrition improved after the Soviet revolution, and the last time USSR had a famine was in 1940s. CIA data suggests they ate just as much as Americans after WW2 peroid while having better nutrition:

USSR moved from 58.5-hour work weeks to 41.6 hour work weeks (-0.36 h/yr) between 1913 and 1960:

USSR averaged 22 days of paid leave in 1986 while USA averaged 7.6 in 1996:

In 1987, people in the USSR could retire with pension at 55 (female) and 60 (male) while receiving 50% of their wages at a at minimum. Meanwhile, in USA the average retirement age was 62-67 and the average (not median) retiree household in the USA could expect $48k/yr which comes out to 65% of the 74k average (not median) household income in 2016:

GDP took off after socialism was established and then collapsed with the reintroduction of capitalism:

The Soviet Union had the highest physician/patient ratio in the world. USSR had 42 doctors per 10,000 population compared to 24 in Denmark and Sweden, and 19 in US:

Here are some academic studies on USSR that you can read instead of trolling here

Professor of Economic History, Robert C. Allen, concludes in his study without the 1917 revolution is directly responsible for rapid growth that made the achievements listed above possilbe:

Study demonstrating the steady increase in quality of life during the Soviet period (including under Stalin). Includes the fact that Soviet life expectancy grew faster than any other nation recorded at the time:

A large study using world bank data analyzing the quality of life in Capitalist vs Socialist countries and finds overwhelmingly at similar levels of development with socialism bringing better quality of life:

This study compared capitalist and socialist countries in measures of the physical quality of life (PQL), taking into account the level of economic development.

This study shows that unprecedented mortality crisis struck Eastern Europe during the 1990s, causing around 7 million excess deaths. The first quantitative analysis of the association between deindustrialization and mortality in Eastern Europe.

Finally, we can look at what people who lived under communism feel now that they got a taste of capitalism have to say:

[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 year ago (1 children)

Looks like you have done this before but I got questions: If the Russians love communism, why haven't they elected them back to power in Duma instead of Putin's party and letting themselves sit as the second biggest party? Why do you pretend that China has not got the second biggest prison population? How many political prisoners does the west have, aside from Assange, compared to the Soviet Union? How many Soviets were arrested for making jokes as opposed to Westerners? How many people left communist countries than leave capitalist ones?

[–] [email protected] -3 points 1 year ago (1 children)

If you're genuinely curious then you can read chapters 6 and 7 in this book on how Russia transitioned into capitalism https://valleysunderground.files.wordpress.com/2020/04/blackshirts-and-reds-by-michael-parenti.pdf

Meanwhile, the current party is basically controlled opposition. Russia is now ruled by capitalists just the same way as western countries are.

Why do you pretend that China has not got the second biggest prison population?

Why do you still pretend that it does when I gave you two separate sources saying that it does not. Do you not understand the concept of per capita perhaps?

How many political prisoners does the west have, aside from Assange, compared to the Soviet Union?

This is your idiotic argument, so why don't you tell me.

How many Soviets were arrested for making jokes as opposed to Westerners?

Show me Soviets who were arrested for making jokes.

How many people left communist countries than leave capitalist ones?

Tiny percentage of people left communist countries, meanwhile people who'd love to leave capitalist countries don't have the means to.

You keep on digging there buddy, can't believe you do this clown act for free.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) (1 children)

Marxism advocate violent revolution, and if Russians do indeed support communism. Why haven't the Russians overthrown Putin yet? If they have done so with the tsar, why haven't they done with Putin? Why haven't the Russians supported the coup against Gorbachev to retain the Soviet Union if they are indeed supportive? How would you address the Soviet Union having had the most prisoners per capita, while it took the United States decades longer to attain similar rate? If it is better in communist states, why are we not seeing people moving to communist countries en masse? Why have we seen more East Germans risked getting shot escaping the Berlin Wall, than West Germans crossing to the east? Why do you think we see more Cubans trek the sea perilously across the Caribbean to leave Cuba than people going to? What do you make of people arrested in the Soviet Union for arbitrary reason? If you are what you claim to be, have you actually heard what they say or do you deliberately ignore them? There should be plenty of Russians still alive to tell their experience being imprisoned for making jokes or simply having farms who you could talk to, no? Do their experience matter to you? If communism is better in Russia, why has it fallen?

[–] [email protected] -3 points 1 year ago (1 children)

No, Marxism does not advocate violent revolution. I've explained this to you earlier, but due to poor reading comprehension you're still repeating falsehoods here. What Marxism says is that the conditions that capitalism creates ultimately lead to revolutions.

Why haven’t the Russians overthrown Putin yet?

Because conditions aren't right. Again, if you weren't an ignoramus, and actually read about history of revolutions, you'd understand when and why they happen. You can start by reading this book from Ray Dalio who is a very successful capitalist, so can't be accused of being a Marxist.

Why haven’t the Russians supported the coup against Gorbachev to retain the Soviet Union if they are indeed supportive

They did, and I linked you a book discussing this in detail in the comment you're replying to. You obviously didn't read the linked source because you are just a troll and aren't actually interested in answers to the questions you ask in bad faith.

To sum up, you don't actually care about answers to the questions you're asking. You are here to troll and that's just pathetic to be honest.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 year ago (1 children)

Muscovites stopped the communist hardliners from overthrowing Gorbachev and backed Yeltsin's support of Gorbachev. Wouldn't you say that this is essentially stating that the Russians do not support communism?

If the standard of living in Soviet Union is better than today and communism is better overall, shouldn't that push Russians to overthrow the current Putin government? Why did communism fall in your opinion?

How come you haven't addressed my questions about prisoners in the Soviet Union and of their experiences? How come you are giving me questions as answers, to my query as to why East Germans tend to risk their lives crossing to West Berlin and more Cubans are attempting to leave than Westerners risking their lives to come in to communist states?

[–] [email protected] -4 points 1 year ago (1 children)

thanks for once again confirming that you can't read

[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago) (1 children)

Will you answer my questions or not? Why did more people risk their lives to leave Cuba and East Germany than the other way? Why hasn't the Russians revolted against Putin despite the excesses of his government? He has high approval rating of 80%. Wouldn't you say that the Russians actually support him and the system he upholds more than the communism? Wouldn't you say there is reason as to why communism fell, and now Russians appear to be more supportive of the current status quo?

Libertarians support unregulated free market because they benefit from rising stocks and worker exploitation. Are you a communist because you are jobless and on welfare? Considering how quick you reply with pre-packaged gish gallop comments, perhaps you do not work at all or ever at all? Or do you extort farmers and such? Do you benefit from communism in one way or another? Did you just admit that atrocities in communism is okay, since capitalism does it anyway? Do you believe that two wrongs make a right? Do you relish in power or getting free stuff from communism to have become its supporter?

[–] [email protected] -4 points 1 year ago (1 children)

I've tried answering your questions, and it's pretty clear that you just ignore what I say and keep repeating the same thing over and over. You're just a troll, and I'm not going to waste more time feeding you. If you're genuinely interested, then go and read all the materials and resources I provided you above. Of course, you're not going to do that because you're just here to troll. I do feel sorry for you, hope you get the help you need one day.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 1 year ago (1 children)

No you haven't. Do you, or do you not approve of mass arrest under the Soviet Union? Did you speak to anyone arrested by Soviet secret police before? Are you a welfare benefit receiver? Do you have a job to keep you busy enough? Is this why you are a communist?

[–] [email protected] -4 points 1 year ago (1 children)

All your questions are answered, all you have to do is work on your reading comprehension.

Bye.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 1 year ago (1 children)

Anyone with half a brain and could read elementary level will see that you have not answered all my question.

We both admit that the West is flawed. However, just a yes or no. Do you acknowledge that USSR has wrongfully imprisoned and created atrocities that is just as morally bad?

[–] [email protected] -4 points 1 year ago (1 children)

I've literally answered this question in detail in several replies. Please work on your reading comprehension.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 1 year ago (1 children)

Just answer the questions with yes or no that's what I am asking of you. Do you approve of Soviet mass imprisonment and purges that happened? Have you spoken to those who were imprisoned? Are you jobless and on welfare?

[–] [email protected] -4 points 1 year ago (1 children)

I already answered this question. Why don't you answer this question, if you have two imperfect systems and one results in less suffering than the other which system is better?

[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 year ago (1 children)

A rational person would choose the less imperfect system. So, by asking me this question, does this mean you acknowledge and approve the arbitrary imprisonment of Soviet citizens by the government? Are you implying that that is better?

You also did not answer other questions though. If you think the communist system is better, why did it fall? Why do people risked getting shot crossing the Berlin Wall from the east, and Cubans crossing the Carribean, than the other way around? If life is better in communist system, why did so many emigrate despite guaranteed and free basic necessities provided? Do you just want to get free stuff to wilfully turn a blind eye to state repression? Have you spoken to former detainees? Do you have a job?

[–] [email protected] -3 points 1 year ago

Except there wasn't any arbitrary imprisonment. That's just something you pulled out of your ass and keep repeating. Just like in any system, some people ended up being detained wrongly. It's on you to show proof that more people were systemically than under other systems. It certainly appears that US wrongly detains far more people than USSR ever has.

If you think the communist system is better, why did it fall?

Plenty of capitalist regimes fall all the time. Using your logic that's sufficient reason to abandon it yes?

Why do people risked getting shot crossing the Berlin Wall from the east, and Cubans crossing the Carribean, than the other way around?

Why did vast majority of people not do this?

If life is better in communist system, why did so many emigrate despite guaranteed and free basic necessities provided?

They didn't, very tiny percentage of people leave communist systems, and it's never to get basic necessities. I guess we've already established that you don't even understand basic concepts like per capita.

Do you just want to get free stuff to wilfully turn a blind eye to state repression?

No this is just an idiotic thing you keep repeating because you think it's a really clever gotcha. You're clearly ok turning a blind eye to repression under capitalism though since it's the system you keep defending here.

Have you spoken to former detainees under your capitalist regime?

Do you have a job?

I do, and I almost certainly make more than your dumb ass.