I see what you’re saying, but I think it’s important to clarify the distinction between privacy and anonymity. While platforms like Lemmy and Mastodon might not be the pinnacle of privacy (let’s be real, the most privacy-conscious choice would be to avoid these sites altogether), I believe they offer the best alternatives to the data-driven practices of FAANG products.

If I recall correctly, Lemmy and Mastodon require an email for registration but don’t ask for your cellphone information. This allows you to create a pseudonyb and alias. It allows you the freedom to engage without worrying about a direct connection back to your identity. Sure, there’s still some risk associated with your IP address, but for most people the level of data collection on these platforms isn’t a significant concern. The fact that there’s no monetization of your data means that your conversations—or lack thereof—are private to you and the users you choose to engage with.

Digital independence is about creating spaces where we can interact freely and securely. These platforms allow us to prioritize our privacy, even if they don’t guarantee complete anonymity. It’s all about finding the right balance and choosing platforms that align with our values regarding privacy and data usage.