Context: A local movie app have this warning to me as I have this domain blocked with NextDNS ๐
this post was submitted on 20 Oct 2023
136 points (94.7% liked)
Crappy Design
3052 readers
1 users here now
Noticed that theres no equivalent to r/crappydesign here yet so i made one
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
This is actually great design.. you are being warned about a breach in privacy. How's the bad design?
The two options are both "No". If you aren't going to give an option, don't give an option. It's confusing to have two options that are the same thing.
Fair.
If you blocked it at the DNS level, I'm surprised the error wasn't a resolution failure. Who's on the other side of this connection pretending to be Google Analytics??
next DNs probably redirects it to a landing page or something
You're probably right. Rather than responding with NXDOMAIN, they're probably synthesizing A or AAAA records that point to their own server. IMO, this is super weird behavior in the era of HTTPS. I'm also pretty sure there's an IETF RFC that says recursive resolvers "MUST NOT" synthesize address records, but I can't seem to dig it up on my phone (pun intended ;).
It's an option, default off. If you enable it it prompts you to install the CA for the block page.
They ask you to install a root CA? That would enable your DNS provider to MITM your TLS traffic. Yikes.