Is the ban for recording it or for SHARING it?
this post was submitted on 04 Jan 2024
72 points (92.9% liked)
Xbox
5239 readers
65 users here now
An Xbox community for Lemmy!
UNIVERSAL XBOX SUBSCRIBE LINK - CLICK HERE
Click this to open this community in your Specific Instance, then click Subscribe
Rules:
- Stay on topic.
- No hate speech.
- No Politics.
- No console wars. We are all gamers.
- No Clickbait
- Be a decent human.
- No piracy talk or links to copywrited content.
QUICK START GUIDE AND RULES:
New to Lemmy?
View the Getting Started Guide
Attributions:
Xbox Logo: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:XBOX_logo_2012.svg
Banner : https://www.xbox.com/en-us/wallpapers/
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Recording uploads clips automatically to MS servers so that you can share it, but they have a no explicit content rule so it automatically counts as an infraction
Let me guess, you can't opt out of uploading the clips
You can, it's just on by default.
Huh, I expected less from Microsoft, I'm actually pleasantly surprised.
Simply recording.
Not really. It was the public sharing that got them in trouble.
Maybe they didn't intend to share it, but the default settings are to share all clips.
No, it still wasn't shared, just automatically uploaded.
Right. It was automatically uploaded to a server that is publicly available. That's sharing, regardless of whether a "Share" button was involved.
From what I read, the content was not publicly available, just uploaded.
Perhaps this sentence is ambiguous, and open to interpretation, but to me it sounds like it was unintentionally shared.
According to Vegas, he didn’t intend to share the footage, but the console settings upload these by default
EDIT: I just logged out and checked online. All my clips are available to anyone who goes looking for them. They are public when automatically uploaded.
Uploading does not necessarily imply sharing. I don't share most things I upload to servers, automatically or manually. Perhaps sharing was also done automatically, but that's not clear.
Do you have an Xbox or any experience with their clip system? You can hypothesize based on other systems you are familiar with, but it won't change the reality of what Xbox does.
I just tested it, and you can too. All my clips are available online (most of them are just me accidentally hitting the clip button.) I logged out of my account, searched my gamertag and was able to access them all as a random person on the Internet.
OK, so that's a detail conspicuously missing from the articles I've read. Seems like it's Microsoft's fault.
Sad little console bros.
Me on pc recording all the nudes - saving it to my joint Xbox / pc OneDrive whahababbaa
How long before Fox News reports this as a PORN GAME
Think of the children!