Concerns about the fediverse (lemmy.world)

submitted 1 year ago by [email protected] to c/[email protected]

15 comments fedilink hide all child comments

Now that reddit started dying, people are exploring the fediverse. I'm one of these people and I found lots of inconveniences, which I want to share with you. Lets get a conversation going.

There are tons of instances which "communicate" with each other, but in reality they are pretty much separated. I tried to connect to some Lemmy instances from Mastodon but it repeatedly gave me "not found" results (even though Lemmy itself said I should try that, see pictures).

-What happens if a server goes down or a server keeper decides they want to modify some post or comment? It doesn't seem much different from what spez did, except now you put everything in the hand of another random person. Legal issues are potentially even worse in this case because there is no company behind the site to blame for their wrongdoings.

-You have to create tens of accounts if you want to post on other instances. Yeah, you might be able to subscribe to communities from one instance but you can't post there, only on your own. Maybe I'm missing something here but it doesn't seem like you can post to the communities of other instances.

-Alternatively: create the same community in your instance? That would just make useless duplications or even separate instances even more...

There are lots of other issues with the fediverse, these are just from the top of my mind. Feel free to share your thoughts, annoyances, or even clarifications.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[-] [email protected] 10 points 1 year ago* (last edited 1 year ago)

What happens if a server goes down or a server keeper decides they want to modify some post or comment? It doesn’t seem much different from what spez did, except now you put everything in the hand of another random person. Legal issues are potentially even worse in this case because there is no company behind the site to blame for their wrongdoings.

You put everything in the hands of many random people :). This is fundamentally no worse than the situation with Reddit.

You have to create tens of accounts if you want to post on other instances. Yeah, you might be able to subscribe to communities from one instance but you can’t post there, only on your own. Maybe I’m missing something here but it doesn’t seem like you can post to the communities of other instances.

That is not correct. I'm not sure what issue you're having, but if you give more details about what you've tried maybe we can help.

Alternatively: create the same community in your instance? That would just make useless duplications or even separate instances even more…

Again, no different from the current state of reddit, you just have many Gaming@whatever instances instead of /r/gaming, r/truegaming/, /r/really_true_gaming_for_real, etc.

There are absolutely rough edges here, but to be honest I think a lot of people either weren't around or don't remember the early days of Reddit. There were a lot of rough edges back then too.

[-] [email protected] 2 points 1 year ago

Okay, I'll take back my point about having to create more accounts. What happened was that when I clicked on "Post" I was redirected to the login page of the instance even though I was subscribed to lemmy.world. My guess is that I somehow went to the other community sites without using lemmy.world and so it didn't realize I was a user of another instance.