If corporations refuse us ownership, then we will reclaim it by piracy.
“If buying isn’t ownership, then piracy isn’t theft” is fun to chant with defiance...and it's super clever. But it's not a full argument—and if we’re going to play the civil disobedience card, we need more than a slogan.
At the deeper level, the licensing regimes that govern digital content make ownership impossible. Even physical media—like a CD—come with licensing restrictions. And the terms are not negotiated or consensual; we are forced to accept binding conditions in order to participate in the cultural conversation. Meanwhile corporations reserve the right to change these contracts unilaterally without our consent. This is not a contract; it’s coercion. It is not between equals; we are being bullied.
What’s truly at stake here is dignity. The right to own something is a basic form of autonomy—not lease it indefinitely and lose it if we no longer ante up our monthly dues. With our autonomy goes our agency. We’re left dependent on sociopathic, profit-driven, shareholder-appeasing corporate players who can change terms beneath our feet. Past investments we've made into our accounts count for nothing; the game is to keep us on a short leash and feeding their endless money glut.
Civil disobedience requires a public articulation of our cause. That’s what this subreddit does, and it has already been noted in mainstream media. We have begun to make our case. However, critics will say that our anonymity weakens our case. But this misses another point we're making: the same corporations that deny us ownership also deny us privacy and commodify our identities. Tracking our behavior and harvesting our data is how they manipulate and monetize us. Remaining anonymous is not cowardice—it's rebellion against a system that has made our visibility a form of vulnerability. It frees us from their control and unnerves them when they can't bully us directly and must deal with us as a movement.
So yes, piracy is rebellion, protest, civil disobedience for our digital age.
Treat us like humans. Treat us with dignity again—and we’ll gladly leave the high digital seas. Break the stranglehold of capital on our necks; put a leash on these monopolies by severing content creation from content delivery to allow true competition again.
Until then, ARRRRRR! this is how I fight back.