I don't think Meltzer giving his opinion of a match is in itself an issue, but there definitely is a sub-group of people on the likes of r/SC that take his word as gospel.
At the end of the day, the decent sheets with actual sources ^(queue^ ^separate^ ^debate)^ are just reporting what they've been told by insiders, and just because it didn't happen doesn't mean it wasn't a possibility. Discussing these possibilities are half the reason we're in communities about wrestling to begin with!
The real problem is that some people can't handle the fact that plans do actually change. ^shrug^