That's a nice thought. Thank you for sharing
this post was submitted on 11 Feb 2025
152 points (98.1% liked)
Privacy
33589 readers
762 users here now
A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.
Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.
In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.
Some Rules
- Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn't great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
- Don't promote proprietary software
- Try to keep things on topic
- If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
- Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
- Be nice :)
Related communities
much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
I asked the man how come and he said “Well, dumb TVs are hard to get and they sell almost immediately. So they’re worth more than the smart ones.”
He's wrong. They're cheaper because the manufacturer makes money off selling advertisements.
I suspect the vast majority of people are buying dumb TVs because android TV sucks, not for privacy reasons. I'm willing to bet most go home and plug their Chromecast or FireTV stick right in.
So as long as android TV sucks, its good news for us.
I dunno that's entirely accurate - we have a Sony Bravia android TV (working on moving away from default OS but that's another story) that is perfectly usable with Stremio and Jellyfin and doesn't have massive invasive ads. One of my parents has a dumb TV with a Chromecast and it's nothing but a PITA to use by comparison.
Not all android TVs are bad, but I think a lot of the cheap ones are pretty bad. Mine is horribly laggy, and will occasionally refuse to turn on unless I powercycle it.
Which Chromecast do your parents have? The ones pre-Google TV are pretty brainless to use, but I hate the new google TV ones as well.
Smart TVs are subsidized by selling your data.
"subsidized" – TVs sold perfectly well before they were flooded with ads. Ads and selling user data just mean more money for CEOs. Always more, MORE, MOOORE PROFIT!
Yes because 3k I paid for the large oled needed to be subsidized 🤡
If they can make money off you, they will.
I've always wanted to ask a billionaire how much was enough, but I'm pretty sure he wouldn't understand the question. Enough? What's that?
That's why I deny the parasite engagement and profit, every chance I get 🐸
We got a class war on our hands, normies are just oblivious
Dumb TVs aren’t subsidized by ads
Neither are all but the cheapest smart TVs.
It's called double and triple dipping. Every single company that can get away with double, triple, quadruple dipping can and does.
Buying the initial product + Subscription + selling your data + dropping support to force you to buy a new product is quite commonplace. The old mantra of "if you are not paying, you are the product" doesn't apply anymore because most companies do both.
Well normies accept abuse, why would my daddy capital NOT extract that extra profit.
Look up "commercial displays" - that'll get you what you're looking for!
It's exactly what I got: it has the telltale PCMCIA connector on the side and a store mode in the menu.
Simple solution: buy a smart TV and never connect it to the internet.
Many smart TVs still give you popups telling you to connect to the internet or they simply refuse work without connection. There's not a very good way to tell if any smart TV you get will do this ahead of time without looking over reviews, and even then many people just connect their TVs anyway so it might not show up there either.
I'd prefer to just have a display that works as a display from the start and not have to worry about it.
Ask the sales rep if it works without internet, and if they're wrong, demand a refund.
if u dont connect to the internet, wont it be dumb?
Often it will yell at you every day and be very intrusive, not actually disconnect from the internet and force join any old WiFi connections/any non-password protected ones, or simply refuse to work unless you connect them (I think some people were saying newer Samsung TVs do that)
When your teevee behaves like Harvey Weinstein....
My neighbor has a smart TV and it keeps bitching and moaning when it's not connected to the internet.
I got a Sharp Android smart tv last year when my 2006 Samsung died and it works great without internet access. Cheapest one there was.
Now I'm picturing the TV sounding like Marge Simpson's sisters.
If you are not able to find a dumb TV, I recommend Google based TVs (GTVs). Unlike some Roku based TVs, GTVs will boot and work just fine even if you never configure their network access. If you do opt to enable network access on a GTV, you can set up static IP addresses on them, including PiHole as DNS.
My wife likes the convenience of a smart TV in her office so I DMZ'd it so that it has no access to our home network and it goes through a dedicated PiHole on a Pi Zero. Neither the Roku or LG TVs we had allowed for this, so I sold the RokuTV and I connected the LG to a thin client with a Bluetooth remote.
PS: Hisense makes a great 4K TV that goes to shit the moment you connect it to the network because of inadequate computing power, low memory, and bad code (memory leaks). If you don't connect it to a network and use it as a dumb TV, it is great display for very little money.
Hit up thrift stores they always have a pile in decent shape. Just test them at an outlet
What store was this? And what was the brand of the TV?
It's a store in Sweden where I reside 6 months per year, and the brand is Finlux.
Must be a good store if you stay there half the year
lol
This won't work if you use actual, classic TV. But I researched for a fair while and found none of the dumb TVs are cheaper than low end smart TVs. Not by a long shot. So I got a giant computer screen instead. I just connect my switch or my laptop.
Just an FYI that the Smart cancer has already began infecting computer monitors. It won’t be long until there are no more dumb monitors.
Samsung and LG make smart computer monitors. There are probably many others.
Well that just made my day a little worse