October 2023: "Having too many types of booster is hurting sales, so we're consolidating them."
July 2024: "Hey check out this new type of booster we came up with."
this post was submitted on 10 Jul 2024
14 points (100.0% liked)
MTG
1835 readers
14 users here now
Magic: the Gathering discussion
General discussion, questions, and media related to Magic: the Gathering that doesn't fit within a more specific community. Our equivalent of /r/magicTCG!
Type [[Card name]] in your posts and comments and CardBot will reply with a link to the card! More info here.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Something something pendulum swinging
WotC exec is schizophrenic. They will never give up trying to give players less while charging them more. The never-ending cancer of "line must got up every year".
You can just create a sustainable business model guys... one where costs are recovered and a modest return is made. You don't need to give in to the squeeze from Hasbro to milk your product into the ground... and become like every other empty shell of a product they own.
Not just line go up. Line must go up more than it has previously gone up. A slightly lesser growth is apparently lethal
It'll never happen, but the only way to make Magic better for the players is if Hasbro sold off WoTC. I can't even come up with a scenario that would cause them to sell, it seems to be the only thing keeping them alive.
@mike and it's too big to be brough by anyone who would act noticbly better.
Unlessit has already 'died'
Yeah that's a very good point. If WoTC starts getting their lunch eaten by a rival game (cough Sorcery Contested Realm cough) or if anything else happens that starts tanking demand then I could definitely see them selling it off for the short term gain while they "regroup on traditional games in their product lineup".
Are these for vending machines or something?
I fail to see where is the "value" in a booster full of commons and uncommons
Saw this on the reddit thread and did a real lol:
It's a value booster for their shareholders
Not more boosters again...
These feel really bad for any enfranchised players, but my guess is that these are meant to be for complete newbies who don't care about resale value or playability. The idea is that kids can drop a buck on some cards that look cool, and be a gateway into wanting more cards later on, or people can use them as stocking stuffers or Halloween treats.
No established player should spend money on this. I know it feels predatory to offer "low value" boosters like this to the uninformed, but the uninformed were never going to sell their cards to a shop.
At the size of half a pack, and without a guaranteed rare, I really hope they don't retail for more than $0.99-$1.50. If they hit $2 then they're truly a failed product.
As a side theory, these could just exist to drive people to more willingly spend on Play Boosters. It's like the small soda at fast food restaurants; it's a small price jump to get considerably more value, so the Play Boosters looks way better in comparison to this cheap product.
I honestly think they're going to try selling these for $3, which is absolutely bonkers nuts but I think their plan was to raise the "normal" booster price and then sell this garbage for around the original booster price.
If these hit $3, I don't see anyone going for them.
@meant2live218 @mike aren't the essentially half of a regular pack? So half the price would be reasonable.
Half the size of a regular pack, but without a guaranteed rare. Play Boosters will have a guaranteed rare, and with the wildcard slot may have a second rare. Even if WotC doesn't want to acknowledge the secondary market, they know that a lot of the "value" of a pack comes from the rare/mythic hits.
@meant2live218 my head is still regular = draft. So ~ a third of a play booster, price should match.
1/3 is a close enough ratio that I'm okay with that. If a Play booster is $4.50, this being at $1.50 feels reasonable. If a Play booster is $6, then this being $2 feels like it may lose the "so cheap" feel that makes it enticing as a random pickup for a non-player.