I totally respect this being potentially a big ask, but does anyone have a TL;DR of what caused or was the fix for the federation issue(s)? I don't have capacity at this moment to look through Github Issues and PRs, but I'm curious
this post was submitted on 10 Jan 2024
182 points (100.0% liked)
Announcements
152 readers
78 users here now
Official announcements from the Lemmy project. Subscribe to this community or add it to your RSS reader in order to be notified about new releases and important updates.
You can also find major news on join-lemmy.org
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
From the little I saw (and zero Rust, or Tokio (I think they use that) knowledge) ... federation workers weren't persisting correctly whenever it would hit certain errors or problems.
Glad to see the federation bug finally fixed
Does this mean we are gonna be able to see comments from other instances? I sometimes see post with a certain number of comments (in the hundreds) but when I open the post I only see a fraction of them.
Possibly, but this is more likely related to your language settings, not having undetermined selected.
should "undetermined" be renamed to "show all" or something?
"Any" I think would be the best way to say it
That sounds correct for the user settings form, but not for the comment / post creation form. Open up an issue on lemmy-ui's gitbub for this if you would.
Yup, for some reason, I had no language selected at all..
I have a feeling the vote thing will be abused.
Lemmy is one of the few ones platforms that attempts to preserve vote and mod action privacy, to prevent harassment, and encourage ppl to vote honestly. Several other platforms just let any user see who voted, which isn't the best idea since it's been shown that ppl are less likely to be honest if they know that their votes are public.
The main reason I added it for admins, is bc a lot of ppl have been understandably upset by downvote-stalkers, or those who downvote with multiple accounts.
Like anything, there's the possibility for abuse, but at least by limiting it to admins only, we can prevent a lot of potential harassment that other platforms are currently allowing.
Admins had the ability to see the votes if they really wanted to anyway by looking at the database, you just made it a lot easier.
Thank you for the explanation. I admittedly am a bit cautious about this feature. But I can see how it can be a powerful tool to prevent bullying.
Hopefully we can trust our admins. But theoretically a bad actor could make an instance that federates with everyone and then takes this info and posts all the vote counts publicly for every post and every comment. And if we don't know which instance is the one responsible, we wouldn't be able to defederate from them to stop them from getting this info.
Not that this feature is the cause of that. Admins could already do this with a db query. And I don't think there is any way around that without making votes completely uncrackable. Just kind of thinking out loud.
Well, the "not seeing votes" definitely is, on both Lemmy and Reddit. All this does is make that abuse observable.
Great news!
Is this just the backend, or is it UI too? Is there an easy way to find this out myself in future?
Releases are always for backend and frontend together, unless mentioned otherwise. You can check the tags in the git repos, or check the available versions on docker hub.
My mod actions are still not being federated. This hasnt worked for me since maybe 0.18.1 or 0.18.2?
I can't speak for others, but I still seem to be experiencing issues with federation. I've got a comment in here that isn't showing up on other instances.
Today I can say I can see the comment on my instance. Quite possibly it took some time for federation to catch up after being broken for a while.
Yeah that's my theory. I think the workers were busy catching up on the whole backlog of all the comments and posts that had built up over the ~3 week period it wasn't working.
Confirmed, I can't see that comment on my instance.
I think there may be an issue with your instance, because my comment is now showing up on starktrek.website, lemmy.world, etc.
Shortly after my instance upgraded, things seemed not to be federating correctly, but now, everything seems to be working. I suspect that was because the wokers were going through a big backlog of posts & comments that had accumulated in the lengthy time federation was not working. But now, everything seems to be working as expected between my instance and the other larger instances.