this post was submitted on 02 Feb 2024
541 points (100.0% liked)
196
16423 readers
1901 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Meanwile Forest Knife-Ears in Warhammer:
Setting foot in our forest? Bad move!
That feel when you gaslight the Fantasy French into worshipping your God Queen and then kill them for trying to see her.
Yeah, but that's a fun recreational time!
Also that feel when you save the Fantasy Holy Roman Empires future Emperor because reasons.
Seriously the biggest flex Karl Franz ever did was encounter the wood elves as a child and not get fed to the trees. Add on the fact that they showed him respect as a child and the elector counts shouldve put him on the throne instantly.
And don't even tell them about the Deldar
Those are 40k.
And DElfs aren't Forest Knife-Ears.
But yes, those are even worse.
Eldar means elf, we know this because Tolkien invented the term and said it means elf.
While Drukhari and Druchii have a different history, and Games Workshop mostly retconned the idea that the WHFB world existed somewhere in 40k, I have fairly little doubt you could find a WHFB Dark Elf calling themselves Eldar somewhere, at least in a "Eldar is the elven word" kind of way, and culturally they're pretty similar in theme. At least in the "BDSM reaver and slaver Elves that don't believe in consent" kind of way.
Tl;Dr Dark Eldar works for WHFB just fine, because they stole half their ideas and terms from Tolkien anyways. The rest they stole from Moorcock.
Sure Dark Eldar works for Fantasy too, GW stole pretty much everything about Warhammer and cobbled it together. But still, the common nomenclature is DEldar for 40k (although I think they got some copryrightable name a few years ago) and DElfs for WHFB.