Share your thoughts, delights, criticisms, and describe your face when
Please honor Bill and Ted's Law: Be excellent to each other.spoiler
the musical number kicked in.
this post was submitted on 26 Dec 2023
118 points (91.5% liked)
Doctor Who
2404 readers
2 users here now
A good old fashioned Doctor Who Community
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I thought this episode was great and so fun! The song was a surprise but I really enjoyed it, what a great tune. I've found the big dramatic speeches to be too much in the past. For a time with Matt Smith it felt like the Doctor never did anything - he just explained how great he is then the baddies gave up. When he started singing though it was more like he was playing the goblin's game and buying time to find the master knot which I much preferred.
Ruby seems like a clever and kind person and a quick thinker. Brave enough to chase the baby onto the roof, didn't miss a beat when she got thrown into the song, worked out what the Doctor is at the end of the episode. Fantastic.
The Doctor looked really great dancing in the skirt at the start and I thought him and Ruby's band singer were nice touches for enby / gender-non-conforming representation. It felt like he's learned from Jodie's doctor to be more relaxed and fun.
There was a bit at the start where my family said "the Doctor's black" and I just cringed and was glad they didn't watch the previous episodes with Rose in. I really liked her and was thrilled to see a trans actor employed to play her. Really feels like they're stepping up and getting all sorts of people in the Dr Who universe.
All fine points, except:
It's not a skirt, it's a kilt.
Yeah, definitely could be. It's got a tartan pattern but there's no sporran and the camera doesn't really linger in it. In my head it was just the Doctor choosing optimal clothing to look great while dancing xD
Tough to say, though I imagine a sporran would likely throw off The Doctor's groove.
Sporrans are optional. It's just a satchel that many people wear with their kilt to carry personal items, but it's not essential, unless it's part of a full uniform.
Those calves. Dang.
Not Who related, but McAvoy's calves. Holy crap.
It's called a kilt, and it's called that because that's what happened to the first person what called it a skirt. 😏
My headcanon is that it's one of Jamie's he left in the wardrobe, and the Doctor just pleated it up a bit for the club.