this post was submitted on 14 Oct 2023
83 points (75.5% liked)
VeganDE
1523 readers
1 users here now
community is read-only! moved to other instance:
https://discuss.tchncs.de/c/vegande
as a true German-speaking vegan you might also be interested in the German-speaking vegan circle-jerk:
https://discuss.tchncs.de/c/kreisvegs
old community info:
Deutschsprachige Veganys
bitte beachten:
- freundlich sein
- evidenzbasiert: keine tollkühnen Behauptungen ohne Datengrundlage. im Zweifel Quelle(n) mit angeben
- konstruktiv (kein "darauf erstmal ein Steak")
- Inhalte mit NSFW markieren, wenn sie Gewalt an Tieren zeigen
- beim Posten von Links den original Linktitel als Titel verwenden
- Dampf ablassen eher in kreisvegs
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Yet our bodies have barely evolved over the last tens of thousands of years. In that regard equal health of all options is a very bold claim. Just as a vegan dog is not a healthy dog, many of the replacements you mention seem insufficient to me.
I'd be surprised if any significant part of your diet resembles what we evolved to. Our food has been bred for taste and sweetness, and lately also to optimize storage, transport and mostly profit. Instead of seasonal variations we get the same food all year around. Instead of regional food, we consume food grown all over the globe. We consume too much and move too little. But the real scare is we eat too much veggies?
Millions of people, entire cultures even, live on a vegetarian or vegan diet. Including high performing athletes. It's certainly possible.
On the other hand, millions of people live on an omnivore diet so bad it makes them sick.
I'm not saying one is good, the other is bad. It's obviously possible to live a healthy life either way (which was my initial intent in brevity), and it is possible to live an unhealthy life either way. Living meat-free in itself is as healthy or unhealthy as living meat-eating. It depends on how you do it.
You‘re absolutely right. Trying for a more healthy and balanced diet is obviously the way to go. Seasonal and local sources are a perfect goal, also when it comes to the carbon footprint of your lifestyle.
For the vast majority of people out there, reducing their meat consumption is the first apparent issue to tackle.
I do agree with the many benefits of less meat: the ecological standpoint, the nutritional value, the animal wellbeing, the cost…
The key difference is that my conclusion don’t reach as far as yours seam to do.