this post was submitted on 17 Jun 2025
12 points (92.9% liked)

homelab

8051 readers
16 users here now

founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Hey all,

I have some questions and this community has been great with my other ones, I'm hoping you can help me out with these too.

This is the diagram of how I think I want my physical network laid out.

Hardware:

The patch panel has LAN cables I installed in the walls on ports 1-20. The ISP feed comes into the patch panel on port 21.

I was looking at getting a Cisco CBS-220 but I found out that those are EOS/EOL and the Catalyst 1200/1300 replaces them. Also that the C1200/1300's aren't actual Catalyst switches but that's beside the point. I couldn't find exact stencils for the C1300 but just know the Catalyst in the picture is supposed to be a 48 port C1300 with 10G SFP+ ports on the right side.

The Netgate is an 8200. According to Netgate's specs, the 8200 LAN ports operate at 2.5G and if I wanted faster, I'd have to upgrade to the 8300 plus some expansion cards. No need for that.

Questions:

  1. Does this diagram make sense? I want everything in my LAN to be protected and controlled by the Netgate. By connecting the switch to the LAN port of the Netgate and then the WAN of the Netgate to the internet feed, I feel like that accomplishes that goal.

  2. Can the C1300 be connected like this? I would need to get a 10G SFP+ for ethernet, not fibre, which I haven't looked for yet. I know with fiber you have to be careful to match both sides of the connection with the same speed otherwise they won't work. Does the same hold true for ethernet SFP's? Meaning, if I find a 10G ethernet SFP+ (since that's what the Catalyst port is rated for) and plug it into a cable going to the 2.5G LAN port on the Netgate, will they communicate properly?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 1 points 18 hours ago

Ah yeah I see. I didn't design the diagram to a specific layer but if I had to choose one after the fact I guess this would be Layer 1 honestly. I'm really just looking for the physical interconnection of devices and making sure I don't have a path out of the network that doesn't go through the Netgate.

But more specifically, I was looking for information on if the C1300 and the Netgate can communicate on the ports I've put in the diagram or if the mistmatch in speed ratings for the ports would be a problem. As well as if the SFP+ port on the C1300 can even be used as a connection like that. In their documentation, Cisco has an example of use for those ports as stacking ports to other switches. I'll only have the one and won't need to stack any other so I was looking to see if the SFP+ ports can be used for non-stacking purposes.