this post was submitted on 27 Jul 2023
611 points (99.8% liked)
196
16744 readers
1812 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
No I'm not, and you're about three levels behind contemporary gender theory.
"Sex and gender are different!" is some Genderbread Person level understanding that I won't assent to.
How we use them in everyday speech is interchangeable.
Trans women are female.
Trans women have female bodies and female anatomy.
Trans women have female endocrine systems.
I won't let you set up trans women to be othered.
Except when we need specificity, like in this incredibly stupid argument you're having (with someone else, I'll note, not me; I just chimed in to tell you you're both stupid)
And specifically it's a woman's female penis, being engaged sexually by the woman it's attached to's lesbian lover. What are you not getting?
Why you're even doing this
Surely there are better, less stupid, fights to pick
While a marginalized group is being actively genocided?
No, I don't really believe there is.
Let these people—whose sole goal is to hurt trans people—group trans women in with cis men in any category by any name and they will work backwards from whatever that category is and build oppression up around it.
I won't cooperate with that.
If a penis is on a woman that's a female penis.
Congratulations, you've ended bigotry.
You seem to be trying to paint fighting oppression as unhip or futile.
I do not agree.
You be irreverent as you want, I still intend to point out and push back against hurtful and hateful tropes.
Oppression is bad; opposing it is good.
And you're very special and important for doing it. Especially by writing comments online, which is the most important way to fight oppression. I'm glad you're so invested in this.
Can I ask why you're so adversarial with people saying "trans lesbians exist"?
Like you seem to be taking as a personal slight this conversation you weren't even a part of existing.
And what's with this "apathy is cool" attitude of yours that says trying to improve to world is pathetic? It's coming off as very 1992 grunge or 1997 South Park.
Yeah it bugs me seeing people say obviously dumb things with incredible passion.
Anyway if you don't believe sex and gender are different then you're beyond reasoning with, though not beyond mockery.
There's nothing dumb about saying trans women are women and some women are lesbians.
What dog do you have in this fight anyway? Did a trans woman steal your girlfriend?
Sorry, Elon.
See? Whenever you get called out on a ridiculous statement, you retreat to a reasonable statement and then pretend I'm attacking that. It's the same shit I initially called you out for, you can't do that to me. I obviously see right through it. I'm above your paygrade, honey.
I don't think "trans women are women" is a ridiculous statement at all.
Why do you take such affront to it?
And doubling down lol
So you are just here to be a transphobe then?
Just checking.
"I'm confused and my trolling is ineffective, you must be a transphobe!" nice hail mary there.
Nah, you're just calling "trans women are women" a ridiculous statement and that's a pretty transphobic thing for you to say.
You should be nicer to your transgender siblings.
Oh I am, am I?
Are you good buddy?
Why do you hate trans people so much?
Why do YOU hate trans people so much?
They owe me money. Now why do you keep popping in here being an asshole about trans lesbians existing?
I'm fighting on behalf of trans people everywhere, defending them from the literal genocide perpetrated by transphobes like you.
By denying the validity of trans lesbians' identities? By continually butting in with flippancy and transphobic tropes?
That seems counter-intuitive. I would suggest a different strategy if the veracity of your claim as to your intentions is to be accepted.
Stop changing the subject. Why do you hate trans people? You still haven't given me a real answer.
There you go again with that sub-par strategy.
I am beginning to doubt the veracity of your claims.
Going to have to ask you to stop being a sealioning transphobe in my mentions. Thanks.
Says the person who only joined the conversation to pick a pointless fight 🙄🙄🙄
So you're not involved in the discussion, you just want to out yourself as an asshole?
You do you, I guess!