this post was submitted on 15 Jul 2023
1201 points (97.0% liked)
Memes
44932 readers
2125 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Buses are lame. They combine the cons of public transit with the cons of driving a car in a city. I believe in tram surpremacy.
Buses > trams. Something breaks down in bus lane? Bus go round. Breakdown on tram track? Tram stuck.
Trolleybuses the best compromise. Uses electricity without having downtime to charge and weight of lot of batteries and doesn't need tracks (but can still have dedicated bus lanes)
I love trams, light rail, and subway systems. I've had to think long and hard about why. Busses have notable advantages for flexibility and redundancy in the system, so why do I prefer to use a railed transit solution?
For light rail, grade separated trams, and subways it's easy: they're faster in the city. Like... WAY faster. They don't fight traffic so I wait a few minutes (at most) in any city with real transit solutions, ride for a short bit, hop off, and I'm there. Not having to deal with my car is freedom.
So... trams.... why trams over busses?
First of all they're bigger. There's more elbow room and it's easier to get on and off. It's easier for a group of people (see: me and the kids) to all climb on and make room. The doors are larger and it's easier to use multiple doors to load a large group so the people getting on and off a tram can go much faster. There is less shuffling along trying to wedge yourselves into the tram like you're forced to do on a bus.
Second, they're predictable and have a visible route. When I'm walking around, I can tell where the tram will be because I can follow the rails. I don't have to guess what the route will be or where I should go to meet it. Yes, busses have signs every so often, but it's not nearly the same as seeing the rails and knowing I'm on the route. This is especially true if they do move the bus route (which is what everyone who advocates for busses says is a good thing), and I don't know it. The bus is just gone.
Thirdly, the tram drives in a predictable path. I can be near it and know where it's going to go. In fact, whole big crowds of people do it all the time in plazas in Europe. You can walk near the rails and know that you're still safe. Check out the plaza in front of the main train station in Amsterdam. They chose to run the trams right through it, but not allow busses since they weren't safe and predictable enough.
Fourth, they're quiet. Trolley Busses get this too, but trams have had it a long time. They can co-exist with a people-oriented space without being too disruptive. When you sit in a cafe talking with your friends and the tram goes by it's no big deal. When a diesel bus goes by it's incredibly noisy.
Lastly, they're a community commitment. When a city installs a tram, the whole city knows that the route it travels will be supported for a long time. If you choose to live near a stop, you'll have transit. If you're choosing to start a business, you'll want to be close to the tram line so customers can easily get there. The same isn't nearly as true for a bus line. I haven't really pinned down why yet, but there's a very different feel to rolling along on a tram while looking at businesses to visit, and rolling along on a bus. You just don't have the same kind of connection to the street around you on a bus that you do on a tram.
You. You get it.
I totally agree with passenger space, predictability, speed and overall commitment towards development of the parts of the city that the tram goes through.
However I personally cannot agree on trams being quiet at least in my country. They have an incredibly loud squeal when cornering at higher speeds. Sometimes one can hear a tram squealing by half a kilometer away.
The tram supremacy doesn't lie in the inherent nature of the technology but in the way we treat it! Trams get:
In short, they are (usually) treated like public transport. Busses on the other hand are too often treated like just another car that's thrown in with the rest but also has the obligations of public transport. If you treated trams like that (sharing the road, waiting behind cars) they would be even worse than busses.