As someone who believes in traditional gender roles and views women’s primary value in their appearance and domestic skills, "The Apothecary Diaries" is a challenging read. The story follows Maomao, a young woman who ends up in the imperial court and uses her knowledge of herbs and medicine to solve various mysteries. Here’s a critique from a sexist perspective:
Women in Non-Traditional Roles:
Maomao, the protagonist, is portrayed as highly intelligent and skilled in medicine, a field traditionally dominated by men. This challenges the notion that women should focus on homemaking and child-rearing instead of pursuing intellectual or professional careers. Independence and Agency:
Maomao is depicted as independent and assertive, often taking the initiative to investigate and solve problems. This goes against the expectation that women should be submissive and reliant on men for direction and protection. Downplaying Beauty:
Unlike many female characters who are celebrated for their beauty, Maomao’s physical appearance is often described as plain or unremarkable. This undermines the idea that a woman’s value is primarily derived from her looks. Critique of Patriarchal Systems:
The narrative often highlights the shortcomings of the patriarchal structures within the imperial court. Maomao’s success in navigating and sometimes subverting these systems suggests that traditional male-dominated hierarchies are flawed and can be effectively challenged by women. Empowerment Through Knowledge:
Maomao’s expertise in herbal medicine and her critical thinking skills empower her to influence outcomes and command respect from male characters. This shifts the power dynamics typically favoring men and emphasizes the importance of education and knowledge for women.
I think it depends on what the nature of the content is. For me I got feedback from some people about erotic sex scenes I’d written and how they might be problematic for some people. And in general I’ve been told my ideas are very strange. For me I’m not sure if I can write in a more mainstream context, that doesn’t come naturally to me.