A lower bar couldn’t be picked…
this post was submitted on 21 Sep 2023
48 points (88.7% liked)
Futurology
1319 readers
1 users here now
Futurology: A space for the discussion of the future of us - the human organism, and the relationship we have with the spaces we may inhabit.
I have only two rules for this community:
** Respect the Community.**
** Respect one another.**
Freedom of speech comes with freedom to experience consequence.
Enjoy this community, enrich yourself as you enrich others. If you have any questions about this community or how it is run, you are welcome to contact the moderator.
Asstronaut
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Most cases bad city design isn't even caused by bad design, but lack of design, or the influence of political goals interfering in the process and making it shit, or planners having to design around antiquated or otherwise non functional parts of the city and making the outcome less than ideal in the process. if one gave a decent human city planner free reign to do whatever they wished with a blank slate new city they would do good job .
The limits of urban design have next to nothing to do with actual ability. It's the fact that you have to deal with actual people, who very often will loudly disapprove of anything that might even slightly inconvenience them no matter how much net benefit it brings.
Everyone with half a brain knows that, for instance, you probably shouldn't need a permit from the city of San Francisco to verify that your new windows won't excessively disrupt "neighborhood character", or that a defunct laundromat should not be a protected historical landmark (which was of course only designated as such after a proposed housing development on the land), or that a truck depot in Harlem is not a better use of the land than a housing complex that would be 50% subsidized.
All of those are real examples, by the way. This isn't a technological or skill problem. It's a people problem, and the robots aren't going to save us there.
Thank you for posting this. These kind of articles infuriate me. A 10 year old playing Sim City can 'design' a better city than anything we currently have. When the "AI" (AI does not exist) actually fucking builds one that works better, I'll be interested in an article like this. So, never.
Tragic that the only people who manage to buck that trend are racist lunatics like Robert Moses or totalitarian regimes like China.
I'm sure it could avoid the worst of climate change too. The problems in these areas aren't really that we don't know the correct answers, it's that we don't have the political will to do what needs to be done.
The far right has already branded 15 minute cities as a communist plot, imagine how they would respond to a Chinese-originated ML city design tool.
Moat of the problems from climate change involving cities are people ignoring known risks, like building in flood plains. Yeah, the AI will identify the same things as the city planners and insurance companies identified decades ago and people have been ignoring ever since.
Based on our current civilization I beg to differ.
What's going to be a better planner? The guy who does everything 100% by the best practices or the guy who takes shortcuts? Sounds like an AI that was designed around best practices will come up with...well, the best designed city based on our collective knowledge of urban planning.
Not quite sure what your point is here
AI will just spout out the same good advice that professionals have provided and society has ignored. It won't be adding anything new, much less groundbreaking.
If its not 3x3 squares in blue, green, and yellow then I don't want to know.
I am happily becoming more and more of a Luddite
It's a design tool, an algorithm. Not midjourney making the blueprints for your neighborhood. Relax,
It was a joke. I'm really interested in AI dx in medicine because apparently it's more accurate than doctors. No more I havent slept for 16 hours so I think a nipple is stage 2 lung cancer (actually happened to my buddy, he's fine).
So why are you still using the internet and electricity? Go move in with the Amish.
He may not meet the required qualifications of barn building, horse stable management, and child and spousal abuse.
Actually kinda am trying. Trying to find property in the middle of no where to set p little personal self sustaining farm and meadery.