Planning on building a computer but need some advice? This is the place to ask!
Planning on building a computer but need some advice? This is the place to ask! /c/buildapc is a community-driven place dedicated to custom PC assembly. Anyone is welcome to seek the input of our helpful community as they piece together their desktop.
it might be enough if you adjust the fan curves actually
the stock or "silent" curves on my motherboard are hilariously loud so I tunes them down
unless you overclock your AIO should be enough and Noctua fans aren't that much better as most other fans nowadays
I would say custom water cooling. It's not cost effective but it fits your requirements of being as quiet as possible with good cooling. Also you didn't say you dont want to sell your kidneys :P
Custom cooling isn't significantly better at cooling then high-end air coolers or AIOs, but since it so customizable you can scale it to your needs and make it inaudible. You could have lots of rads. Or if you want to keep a small case, you can have something like a large external rad (like a MORA) with large slow moving fans (silent).
Also it's mostly just initial costs that are high. Your AIOs pump won't last forever but you will have to replace the entire thing. You could invest in a better pump in a custom loop, and even if you have to replace it, you can reuse your fittings and rads, and some tubing.
Plus it's cool as hell.
What's the cheapest estimate I can get away with custom water cooling?
it's all about the size of the cooler a massive air-cooler has the most potential for quiet and water cooling you always have the pump
Personally, I'd choose air cool. I have zero confidence about my DIY skills and I want to keep my PC simple.
As you mentioned
as quiet as possible
How much cost are you willing to pay? Bot only money, but also the time you'll spend on it. If you really love digging into it, then I'll suggest go ahead for liquid with caution.