74
This shit angers me so much. I know 10 years or less Nintendo will probably use the emulator to ship a remake a breath of the wild or some shit the same way the use current emulators to charge for their older games
this post was submitted on 27 Feb 2024
74 points (100.0% liked)
Emulation
3370 readers
2 users here now
Community to talk about emulation & roms.
RULES:
1.) No bigotry
LINKS:
-
Emulation Wiki - Your source for everything emulation :)
-
[WIP] Emulation Links Wiki - My personal wiki for emulation links, please help contribute!
-
r/Roms Megathread - Megathread of Roms
-
RetroArch - RetroArch is the popular front-end to libretro which is a simple API that allows for the creation of games and emulators.
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
It's ridiculous. Yuzu is open source too so it's not like they can stop someone from forking it tomorrow anyway.
So how long until Nintendo sues Nintendo for using a pirated version of Super Mario Bros on the Wii U Virtual Console emulator?
If Nintendo can prove that Yuzu is “primarily designed” to give people access to official Nintendo Switch games and has no other real use, Yuzu would indeed be in trouble.
What if people just started making games for the Yuzu engine?
Nintendo doesn’t deserve your time or money. Yes, that ruins my nostalgia & childhood too.
If this succeeds, won’t it set a precedent making emulation of proprietary platforms in general illegal?
It probably won't make it to court because the devs cant afford it. Nintendo knows this which is what makes their actions basically bullying. They wouldn't risk losing in court when they can bully projects into shutting down.
Perhaps but unless there's something different about Yuzu I don't understand, it would have to go against established precedent in the US. For example, I assume Yuzu isn't providing the BIOS so how could it be breaking the law? Reverse engineering (clean room) has always been legal because there's no copyright infringement of the software and thus how else would Nintendo be protected? Meta-copyright? A patent?
I think this is just them trying to screw Yuzu by making them not even attempt a fight in court. Will it stop it now? No. But perhaps Nintendo has a method that would stop Yuzu currently and is trying to kill them before they implement it.
They are arguing that the sticking point is that it subverts the copyright protection measures.
But it still relies on users providing their own keys so that doesn't make much sense either.
Yeah I know but that's like blaming a copying machine for facilitating trade secrets because it copies the cipher text printed on paper. It doesn't decipher it. Someone still has to have the cipher key(s) but they're still blaming the copying machine.
Well, now I won't buy a switch oled. Unsympathetic company