Pathfinder 2e General Discussion

Centaurs may not have reach, if they're classed as Large (Long) instead of Large (Tall). There's a chart in the Size, Space and Reach rules that lays out the difference. The Centaur in the Bestiary works that way. The Minotaur ought to get 10 feet of base reach with melee weapons, though.

Also, larger weapons don't inherently use larger damage dice in second edition. A Tiny greatsword does 1d12 damage, the same as a Huge greatsword. It's possible that Large creatures will get a permanent Clumsy 1 in exchange for a flat +2 damage the same way that Enlarge does, though. That's how they worked the feat-based size increase for Lizardmen. It's also possible they'll just get racial +2 Strength and -2 Dexterity or something instead.

This is the first I have heard of them given I've turned my back on reddit. I could see medium for minotaurs honestly. Just being on the upper bounds but centaurs I really can't unless their body is a pony.

Riding other players is always a terrible idea, and already possible due to stuff like wild shape (or enlarge I suppose).

I can see the reach issue being a problem, one potential solution they could use is to add it as a level 5 heritage feat. Ruling it as needing practice to use your reach effectively or something.

Honestly, removing the damage dice mechanic from PF1 (and a similar problem in 5e), already solves one of the biggest issues of large creatures.

Do all large creatures have reach in pf2e?

Other PCs riding them seems like it can be fun and worked with.

Yeah, fitting into buildings and dungeons was my first thought. Having the extra reach is going to be balanced pretty well with either carrying around shrink potions or always dealing with squeeze mechanics.

I don't think you'd need to Squeeze through either 5-foot hallways or normal sized doors. In theory that's reserved for spaces that just barely fit your shoulders (trained) or just barely fit your head (master).

I'd think both of those would just be difficult terrain. The doorway might be greater difficult terrain, especially if it's particularly narrow or something. Squeezing is pretty debilitating, since it's 10 rounds (one minute) per 5 or 10 feet of movement.

I hope it's not that. Being half horse and going slower would be a hard pill to swallow. I could definitely see that with minotaur though. Bipedal with hooves sounds like a recipe for disaster.