Federation is open by default but I never post anything to my home instance because no one is there. If I started posting on my own instance other people could theoretically subscribe to my communities the same way I subscribe to communities on other instances but since there are only two users on my instance it's pretty unlikely people would find it without me crossposting somewhere.

Benefits of me running my own instance are that I control my own user account and I'm not at the whims of another admin. I subscribe to content on lots of other instances and it all federates into mine which means I've been able to browse content when some of the big instances go down. I've got my own entrypoint to lemmy which feels a bit more neutral than choosing another instance to be 'home' for my user.

Downsides are that I have to pay for and maintain it myself which can sometimes be a serious pain. Because my instance only has two users my 'all' feed is basically a copy of my 'subscribed' feed plus a couple posts from communities that my wife subscribes to that I don't. That can make it hard to find new content without using something like lemmyverse.net.

If you're thinking about hosting your own instance I encourage you to give it a shot. I'd highly recommend the lemmy-ansible project on github which is both a guide and playbook for deploying the various lemmy docker containers using ansible. I'm a sysadmin by trade so running services like this is something I'm pretty familiar with but I've still found myself frustrated by Lemmy more than once. It's still a young project and can be frustratingly brittle and difficult to troubleshoot. That being said it's been a great learning experience and makes me feel like I'm doing my part to contribute to a better and more decentralized web.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 10 months ago

Great write up, thank you

[–] [email protected] 2 points 10 months ago (1 children)

Some follow up, what are the costs related?

I assume you have to pay for a domain.

I already run my own media server from home and I have a spare PC, are you just saying the electrical costs or do you pay for server hosting?

[–] [email protected] 2 points 10 months ago

I host a lot of software internally on my home network too but I didn't want to run Lemmy from my home so I host it in AWS which is not particularly cost-effective. The bulk of the cost is from the vps. I'm not paying on-demand pricing but it's still more expensive than I'd like. I also pay for a static IPv4 address, object storage (for the image hosting) and like you mentioned before, the domain. It's roughly $30 per month although that cost has a small overlap with another service I run on the same vps.

I might start hosting Lemmy locally too at some point mostly to cut costs. I'd like to isolate my more internet-facing software like Lemmy to a separate LAN isolated from the rest of my home network. I have a few things at home exposed to the internet through a reverse proxy right now but with Lemmy being very open and public by it's nature I don't want it mixed in with the rest of my network so I'll probably buy a small block of IPv4 addresses from my ISP before I move it.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 10 months ago (1 children)

Because my instance only has two users my ‘local’ feed is basically a copy of my ‘subscribed’ feed plus a couple posts from communities that my wife subscribes to that I don’t.

But if you switch to "all" instead of subscribed and sort by active or hot you see the popular posts on all of lemmy, right? And you see all the communities under /communities link?

[–] [email protected] 4 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago) (1 children)

No. Only communities that at least one local user is subscribed to are federated into an instance.

And I realize I made a mistake in the feed names. My local feed is completely empty. My 'all' feed is what I was intending to describe with that comment. It is just the communities that either my wife or I have subscribed to. I haven't done this yet but I was reading about a project that admins can add to their instance that effectively creates a phantom user to subscribe to lots of content all across the fediverse. It's intended to help bridge the gap between very small instances and the rest of the fediverse by ensuring that your 'all' feed actually aggregates content from other instances without requiring you to subscribe.

I'm blanking on the name and can't find the posts I saved about it, but I'd really like to try it out to make it easier to come across new communities organically without having to hunt them down.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

Ah thanks, very interesting to know.

It's very unlikely I'm going to run my own instance, although I would like the freedom to tinker with the web client. Probably going to try to just run the UI client locally at some point.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 10 months ago

Nothing manual required, you can federate with any other instance as long as you're not on their ban list.

You basically use your instance's search to search for a community on the remote instance, then your instance requests the top (5?) posts from the community on the remote instance. Once a user subscribes, all new posts going forward will be sent to your server via the federation.

At least I think that's how it works, haha.