this post was submitted on 23 Jun 2023
6 points (100.0% liked)
guitars
3882 readers
243 users here now
Welcome to /c/guitars! Let's show off our new guitar pics, ask questions about playing, theory, luthier-ship, and more!
Please bring all positive vibes to the community and leave the toxic stuff elsewhere.
Rules:
-
Treat others with respect. ALL others.
-
No spam
-
No self promotion
-
No NSFW
-
No circle jerk posts, there are other places for that silliness, and they are wonderful. Not here.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Guitarfetish parts are perfect for a project like this. They are cheap enough that you aren't sinking a ton of money into an already cheap guitar, and are nice enough (given you don't buy their cheapest stuff) that you feel like you've made worthwhile improvements to that cheap guitar.
The biggest thing I'd say is to replace that wraparound bridge with one that has individual adjustable saddles. The way it sits now, intonation is always a compromise, and that's just not a good design from a performance perspective.
After that, the best upgrades you can make to a guitar like this are fretwork and a better nut. Assuming it still has the factory nut and fretwork, it's virtually a guarantee that they are shoddy, and you just won't be able to get it playing as well as it can without addressing those first. That's the big thing people tend to miss while upgrading cheap guitars and why they often end up unsatisfied with the results.
And finally after tackling those issues, then I would start looking into other parts like pickups and tuning machines. There are lots of options on GFS that are both cheap and decent, it's up to you to choose what you like. Check out some sound samples and the like. If you're trying to add a coil split, just make sure whatever pickup you get has four conductor wiring and get a push-pull pot if you don't want to drill any holes, though I much prefer mini toggle switches. If you're trying to add a second pickup, well that is very in-depth for a guitar like this. Doing it yourself will be a nightmare if you don't have experience, and paying someone to do it will cost more than the guitar is worth.
Beautifully put. Toss a GFS humbucker in there with a coil split on a push pull pot and some of their Wilkinson tuners. Parts done!
Just to echo what you said, I wouldn't even bother adding a pickup. You'd have to route a cavity for the pickup and the switch, Make a back plate, And then connect the cavities. Way too much work for very little payoff! And this is assuming he has the skill set to do it without borking it. High risk low reward
You were right in everything. Bridge, nut and fretwork made a massive difference in tunning, sustain and ease to play. You helped me get a new guitar with your advice. Thanks a lot!
The lighting bolt bridge with post screws is intonatable. Unless there are deep grooves it is fine. The pickups/electronics and tuners are where the big upgrade is. The nut could be a big upgrade too. That could just ne d cut properly.
+1 for guitar fetish.
The bridge is intonatable within a general ballpark, but you're never going to get each string dialed precisely without individual saddles. If you aren't playing anything that requires great intonation, that's cool, but better intonation is never not better.
You can intonate a little flat and adjust your finger pressure. The guitar can never be in perfect intonation for all keys and even if it could I'm not sure you would want to.
So long as you are not doing a standard or drop tunig the lightning bolt will be just as good as a tune o matic or Nashville. The lightning bolt even has advantages. It won't add little kinks to your strings so you will have better intonation on broken in strings if you care about being parts of a cent on. The only issue is if you use a set of strings with a wound g or ballenced for an open tuning. If you do one those you won't be able to correct for it and would need a different shaped bolt.
I think we're arguing semantics here. You are absolutely correct, there is no such thing as perfect intonation on an even temperament guitar (check out true temperament necks theyre trip).
However I will outright disagree with you that the lightning bolt is "just as good" as an adjustable bridge. It is certainly possible to have one with perfect intonation at the 12th fret across all six strings but it is absolutely not the norm. So you have to compromise and split the difference on a few strings.
Frankly, I like the looks of a lightning bolt wrap around over an adjustable one all day. But an adjustable saddle bridge is going to outperform it in achieving best possible intonation every time.