this post was submitted on 19 Jul 2024
-4 points (38.9% liked)

Medical Advice

38 readers
1 users here now

Overview

Medical Advice - Making a difference together! Welcome to c/medical_advice! Advice given on this community does not constitute professional medical advice. The circumstances do not mimic those of a review by a health professional. Advice is therefore meant for interest only, in an unofficial capacity, or to help point you in the right direction. Assessment, diagnosis and treatment recommendations are not possible, and all suggestions as such are speculative opinions.

Legal Notice

The information provided on this subreddit is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. We strongly advise you to consult a medical professional or healthcare provider in person if you're seeking medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Anyone providing advice on this subreddit, regardless of verified user flair, is not liable for risks or issues associated with using or acting upon the information provided.

Medical Emergencies

Posting a medical emergency on this community is prohibited.

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

Is it safe to wash your anus with water and your (ungloved) hand after pooping, assuming (of course) that you don't touch anything with your hand until you wash it with soap and water?

I'm currently traveling in India. It's common here, instead of using toilet paper after deification, to pour water down your back and use your left hand to wipe your anus clean of feces. I googled to find information from medical professionals to understand if this is safe or not, but I (surprisingly) couldn't find any information on the Internet about this.

Of course, let's assume that we're doing this properly:

  1. You only use one hand (typically your left hand), so feces only contaminates one hand.
  2. You don't touch anything in the bathroom (eg pitcher, faucet, door knob, etc) with your soiled left hand until after you wash your hands
  3. You wash your hands properly, following best-practices: using soap and water, scrubbing vigorously for at least 20 seconds.

I'm less interested in your personal opinion, and more interested if any studies have been done analyzing the efficacy of safety in this scenario, using a proper scientific study.

Have any studies been done to analyze if it's safe to wipe your ass with your hand (and wash your hands properly with soap and water after)?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] southsamurai 4 points 3 months ago (5 children)

If you're washing your hands properly, you don't have to worry about much of anything tbh. There's a reason hand washing inservices are mandatory for pretty much everyone in anything related to medical care.

You don't need ass-specific studies because the existing studies included bacterial cultures as a measurement.

Seriously, poop isn't some kind of horrible thing that won't wash off. It isn't radiation, it isn't going to burrow in the skin and resist removal. You take care of patients, and you have to poop, most places in the US you're gong to be wiping with paper, which isn't exactly great at protecting the hands. You then wash your hands, and you're good to go as long as you did it right. Gloves aren't mandatory for all contact, believe it or not, and that includes feeding patients. You should wear them for feeding, but not every facility requires it. They should, but they don't. Well, didn't back when I was still working.

More importantly, you aren't likely wearing gloves to feed yourself. You wipe your ass with toilet paper regularly, wash your hands and move on with your day, right? The presence of water in the wiping process is no more or less "clean" than using paper, unless the water is pressurized enough that you don't use your hands at all. Bidets are awesome.

Besides, aren't most of the actual toilets in India the low profile ones, or have the hotels and such started putting in higher ones? I've never been, but it used to be a pretty common culture shock point of interest. When that's the case, or it's one of the squatting toilets that's basically a hole in the ground, you won't have much feces clinging unless you're really hairy and/or your feces is unusually sticky from fats or sugars. Even with loose stools, it doesn't stick.

No bullshit, number 3 on your list makes the rest irrelevant. Yeah, don't be an asshole and grab handles with the "wiping" hand until after you've washed your hands, but in terms of your own safety, that isn't relevant.

The amount of any possible pathogens left on the hands after washing like you described is no greater after wiping than after any other time you wash them. That's why it's done.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 3 months ago

you won’t have much feces clinging unless you’re really hairy

Generally the butt hole has more accumulated feces if it's a soft stool, very hairy, and ... I spent an hour on lemmy, so it's all crusted-up

load more comments (4 replies)